top of page
Dinosaur Birthday
Margarita Cake
White velvet heart cake with wafer butterflies
Pumpkin Cinnamon Roll
Cinnamon Roll Bundt bread
NY Crumb Cake
Courage cake
Carrot Cake
custom order cake
Vanilla Chai cake
Birthday cake
Blue Tres Leches sponge cake with berries
Lemon Bar Cookies
Maple Bourbon Pecan Cake
Maple Bourbon Pecan Cake
Wilderness Animals Cake
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Pumpernickel Bread
Rye Bread
Puff Pastry
Custom Requested cake
Peach Pie
Strawberry Cake
Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Fudge
Strawberry Cake Pops
White Breads
Pumpkin Whoopie Pies
Strawberry Cake with Italian Meringue Buttercream
471246930_1155140719458649_6165234922787696160_n
Snickerdoodle Cake
Croissants
Jumbo Milk Bread Dinner Rolls
Spinach and Chicken Quiche
Snickerdoodle Cake
Pound Cake
NY Crumb Cake
Puff Pastry
Lemon Bar Cookies
Fruit Cake
Sweet Bread
Various Breads
Country White Bread
Rustic Multigrain Bread
Pumpkin Cake
Chocolate Mousse Cake
Birthday Cake
Holiday MenuSome of our regular menu items and some special, just for the holidays! Our regular menu is also available with some restrictions. due to overwhelming demand and the lack of time and equipment to make, we will not be making dinner rolls for holidays. We apologize for this but invite you to enjoy them other times of the year.


Custard Pies



Pumpkin
We roast off fresh pumpkin until it caramelizes and develops a nice, deep flavor and blend with a secret blend of spices. 10-inch $20 12-inch $30


★ The Ultimate Pumpkin
This isn't your grandmothers pumpkin pie! We start with roasting fresh sugar pumpkin and butternut squash, cook it down with brown sugar, fresh grated ginger and nutmeg and infused with vanilla bean, bourbon and maple syrup. We then add more roasted pumpkin, mascarpone cheese and eggs. All of this is then slowly baked and topped with a French inspired white chocolate and maple mascarpone chantilly cream! 10-inch $30 12-inch $45


Sweet Potato
Rich and buttery roasted sweet potato custard and slowly baked to perfection! 10-inch $20 12-inch $30


★ Eggnog
A new addition in 2021 this is your classic vanilla custard pie with a special blend of eggnog spices! 10-inch $20 12-inch $30
$20



Specialty Pies



Lemon Meringue
Creamy lemon inside a pillow of lightly toasted, sweet meringue on the outside! 10-inch $25 12-inch $35


Pecan
A traditional southern pie. Not too sweet, with just the right amount of vanilla and loads of toasted pecans! 10-inch $30 12-inch $40


Apple
The most requested pie, probably of all time and you will find out why if this makes it to your table! 10-inch $30 12-inch $40


Wild Blueberry
Ahhh yes, blueberry. This pie is made from wild blueberries from the great state of Maine! The smaller wild variety are smaller and pack more blueberry flavor than your cultivated varieties sold in your local produce department. 10-inch $25 12-inch $35


Dutch Apple
Shake up the traditional apple pie with our take on a Dutch apple crumb pie! 10-inch $30 12-inch $40


French Apple
Add a bit of love in your pie with this unique apple pie. It is similar to a traditional apple pie but bakes with raisins and topped with a sweet vanilla glaze. 10-inch $30 12-inch $40


Mobtown Brown
Served warm or cold, this is pecan pie is topped with a rich chocolate ganache and house made salted caramel sauce. 10-inch $32 12-inch $40


Cranberry Citrus Pie
To showcase this popular holiday fruit, this pie combines sweet citrus and tart cranberries for a one of a kind dessert. This goes great with optional orange whipped cream. 10-inch $25 12-inch 35. Orange whipped cream add $5


Pumpkin Pecan
A bit of a twist on two traditional holiday pies. If you have ever stressed over whether to have pumpkin pie or pecan pie this just might be your new favorite. Two different fillings, baked together to make this one of a kind dessert. 10-inch $25 12-inch $35


Smores Tart
A unique take on a fun summer time treat.A sweet graham cracker crust , baked in a 12 inch tart pan, filled with rich dark chocolate ganache and topped with a sweet toasted marshmallow meringue! $30


Sweet Potato Meringue
Dare to give this one a try? Rich sweet potato pie with billows of toasted marshmallow meringue! 10-inch $25 12-inch $35


Chocolate Bourbon Pecan
This might be the only thing better than the traditional pecan pie! Unlike a regular pecan pie this one uses a blend of brown white and muscovado sugars, dark chocolate and a vanilla bourbon custard, baked in an all butter pie crust. 10-inch $33 12-inch $45


Rum Mincemeat Pie
A meatless version of a traditional Mincemeat pie. This version is made with raisins, citrus peel, spices and a touch of rum flavor.
$20
Vegetarian



Holiday Beverages
Some of the best holiday beverages can be found right here! Each one of these is carefully crafted for your enjoyment.


Classic Eggnog
a half gallon of a classic holiday beverage. Aged vanilla beans and freshly grated nutmeg make this beverage a step up from your regular holiday nog! half gallon $20 gallon $35
Gluten free


★ Special Eggnog
If you really want something special, this eggnog is truly a winner! Custom blend of a Makers Mark bourbon, 10 year Pierre Ferrand Ambre Cognac, and a 7 year Flor de Cana rum. This eggnog is boozy enough to store in the refrigerator unopened for several weeks to a year! The saying "it gets better with age" definitely applies here! Shake gently before serving. half gallon $35 gallon $70
Gluten free


★ Chilean Monkey Tail Punch
Stories vary surrounding the origins of this punch's unique name. Some say it was initially served in a bottle depicting a monkey with a long tail, but others suggest it was named after a funny incident with a Chilean president in the early 1900s. Whatever the origin, coffee and spirits will make this sweet chilled drink warm you right up this Christmas. Made with Strong premium coffee, Mosto Verde Pisco, milk and a secret blend of spices, this premium beverage is perfect served over ice. Half Gallon $40 Gallon $75
Gluten free


Mulled Cider
Slowly simmered farm fresh pressed apple cider with saigon cinnamon sticks, star anise, allspice, cloves and fresh oranges. Sailor Jerry Spiced Rum adds the final touch to this holiday favorite! Best served hot! $25 half galon $40 gallon non-alcoholic $15 half gallon $25 gallon
Gluten free



Cakes and Cake Rolls



Crumb Cake
Choose from a Brooklyn style crumb cake made with a tender coffee cake crumb with a dark brown sugar crumble or a yeasted German crumb cake with a white sugar crumble called streusselkuchen.
$20


Chocolate Swiss Roll
Traditional Swiss roll with chocolate sponge cake and a vanilla frosting filling, topped with a chocolate glaze.
$20


Triple Chocolate Roll
Chocolate Sponge cake wrapped around a dark chocolate filling and topped with a chocolate glaze.
$20


Pumpkin Roll
Pumpkin sponge cake wrapped around a vanilla bean cream cheese filling.
$20


Gingerbread Roll
Gingerbread Sponge cake with a creamy spiced mascarpone chantilly filling.
$25


Classic New York Cheesecake
Probably the most classic cheesecake of them all. If you don't know what to choose you might as well start with this one. Choose between a graham cracker or shortbread crust.
$40


Cranberry Eggnog Cheesecake
There is something about eggnog and a sweet cranberry topping all baked in a ginger cookie crust. It sounds like a strange combination but it just works.
$40


Chocolate Chip Cranberry Bread
Tart cranberries, sweet chocolate with a brown sugar and cinnamon streusel and icing.
$20


Bûche de Noël (Yule Log Cake) Roll
Bûche de Noël cakes are a French Christmas tradition dating back to the 19th century. This unique take on a cake roll and the traditional yule log is sure to be a new favorite! $25


Figgy Pudding
Contrary to the name, figgy pudding is not a pudding (at least by america's definition). Not your traditional Figgy Pudding but this British style cake is filled with nearly a pound of dried figs and dates puréed with buttermilk, steam baked and iced with a hard sauce glaze made with St. Julian brandy. $45


NY Crumb Cake
A light butter and vanilla cake topped with a cinnamon and brown sugar crumb and generously dusted with confectionary sugar. $20


Maple Bourbon Pecan Cake
Soaked in a warm, boozy maple bourbon sauce, topped with sticky caramelized pecans, this is not your every day coffee cake! Sold as a 10 inch round cake. Can be made in larger rounds and up to a half sheet cake! Inquire about pricing.
$40


Gingerbread
A delicately spiced cake, exquisitely moist and finished with a silky brown sugar Swiss meringue buttercream.
$60
Gingerbread


Pumpkin Spice
A luxuriously moist butter cake made with roasted sugar pumpkin purée, buttermilk, and a signature blend of warm spices, finished with a smooth cream cheese buttercream.
$60


Vanilla Chai Spice
A super moist spice cake infused with fresh ground cinnamon, cardamon, allspice, cloves and fresh ginger, frosted with a sweet chai spice buttercream.
$60


Ultimate Carrot
This carrot cake with pineapple has made lovers of carrot cake who have previously said they hated carrot cake. Full of carrots, pineapple, house made candied pecans, toasted coconut and banana, All frosted with a brown butter cream cheese frosting.
$65



Special Cakes and Desserts
For Thanksgiving these desserts must be ordered at least three weeks in advance! They will be available for Christmas but will be in limited supply. Please order in advance to reserve yours!


Holiday Fruit Cake
A Fantastic addition to any holiday menu! Made with fresh dried fruits soaked in a 7 year Flor de Cana rum, baked on a low temperature and aged with brandy for more than two weeks! 2lb cake $35. Custom sizes available for advance order only.


Aged Fruitcake
Take our fruitcake and turn it up a notch. This fruitcake has been aged for an entire year! Limited supply. $40
Vegetarian

  • Facebook

©2021 by The Natural Baker. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page